In recent years, we have seen an astonishing amount of research being published touting the health benefits of coffee. The question is: do these studies negate the health risks reported in studies past?
In this newsletter, I will dive into this very controversial issue of coffee – when it comes to our health, is coffee a friend, or foe? I will also discuss how different bodies may react to coffee differently based on their constitution, and take a look at coffee through the Ayurvedic lens.
A Shift in Scientific Findings
Experts from the 23rd International Conference on Coffee attempted to explain why there is such a dramatic shift in the research on coffee from so negative, for so long, to mostly positive. They posited that in the past, researchers were actively looking to find proof that coffee was detrimental to health while today, researchers are actively looking for the possible benefits.
Regardless of how the research about coffee shifted, we know that the plethora of contradictory facts has left many of us confused.
Let’s take a look at some of the research on both sides before we can begin to judge for ourselves.
Recent findings show that if you drink one cup of coffee a day, you can reduce your risk of diabetes by 13%, (1) but if you drank twelve cups a day, you could reduce the risk of diabetes by 67%. (2) Twelve cups!
Six cups of coffee a day had an 18% reduction on prostate cancer and a 40% reduction of aggressive lethal cancer. (3)
Four cups of coffee a day could reduce your risk of liver cirrhosis by 84%! (4)
Five cups a day for five weeks began to reverse Alzheimer’s damage in the brain by reducing levels of amyloid-beta, both in the blood and the brain. (5)
One to four cups reduced the risk of Parkinson’s by 47% and five cups a day reduced it by 60%. (6) In this study, the greater number of cups of coffee per day, the lower the risk of Parkinson’s disease.
And while there are many more studies citing the cardiovascular risks posed by coffee consumption, a recent study showed that women who drank 1-3 cups of coffee a day had a 24% lower risk of dying from cardiovascular disease. (7)
High blood pressure – once the holy grail of anti-coffee publicity – is now being questioned. Studies have shown for years that coffee will raise blood pressure, (8) but new studies show that while the blood pressure will go up initially, if you continue to drink it daily for 8 weeks, the blood pressure will normalize. (9)
What’s the secret ingredient?
If you take the caffeine out of coffee, the benefits cited above remain relatively the same. So, if it isn’t the caffeine that is responsible for these benefits, then what is it?
There are about 1000 active constituents in the coffee bean and only a few of them are understood. We do know that the coffee bean, the seed of the fruit, is loaded with antioxidants.
Perhaps the most powerful known antioxidant in the coffee bean is called chlorogenic acid, a compound that is most concentrated in the green, unroasted coffee bean but dissipates somewhat in the roasting process. The weakening of this compound in the coffee bean’s journey from bean to beverage may be why we need such high amounts of coffee to reap its many benefits. Today, green coffee extracts are available to deliver the benefits of chlorogenic acid without actually having to drink the dark roasted brew.
Most of the negative research on coffee can be linked to its impact on the nervous system. Coffee is a stimulant and increases the release of stress hormones, which are usually reserved for life or death, fight or flight situations. (10) The elevation of these hormones is detectable hours after consumption. Interestingly, the release of the same hormones occurs with decaffeinated coffee. (11)
DHEA (dehydroepiandrosterone) is a steroid hormone that decreases with the consumption of coffee. DHEA is responsible for cellular and tissue repair. It also enhances memory and cognitive function, protects against stress, and supports numerous physiological processes. (12)
Coffee consumption (including decaffeinated coffee) releases an addictive neurotransmitter called dopamine. Dopamine is a pleasure hormone and when the brain is bathed in dopamine, it never forgets the source. After the coffee rush wears off, the brain starts thinking about its next cup, so that when a coffee drinker drives by a coffee shop, they may be compelled to stop even if they were not previously thinking about coffee. This is the effect of dopamine on the brain”it’s the addictive I’ve gotta have it hormone. (13)
Dopamine may only be one mechanism for the addictive nature of coffee. Withdrawal symptoms such as painful headaches, nausea, vomiting, loose stools, depression, anxiety, and fatigue are common when a coffee drinker tries to stop. (14)
In addition, coffee:
- Raises homocysteine levels – a major risk factor for heart disease. (15)
- Raises blood pressure. (16)
- Raises cholesterol. (17)
- Is associated with heart irregularities. (18)
- Increases inflammation. (19)
- Damages the nervous system. (20)
- Interferes with neurotransmitters in the brain. (21)
- Alters DNA repair. (22)
- Increases risk of kidney stones. (23)
- Lowers bone density. (24)
- Interferes with sleep. (25)
- Is linked to erectile dysfunction. (26)
- Increases gastric reflux and heartburn. (2)
The Ayurvedic Perspective
It seems that most of the negative research on coffee stems from the damaging effects of the increased production of degenerative stress hormones. Because these effects seem to be true for both caffeinated and decaffeinated coffee, it would be logical to assume there must be other stimulating elements in coffee.
If you are using coffee as a stimulant to get energy, that in itself creates an imbalance. Using a stimulant to create energy you do not naturally have can potentially push you into debt, sometimes referred to as adrenal exhaustion.
Also, coffee, via its dopamine activation, is a very addictive substance that creates highs and lows in energy. In turn, these highs and lows can affect mood and physiological function.
It is also recognized in Ayurveda that coffee has an effect on the quality of mind, stimulating it into a rajasic, or overly active, state. This goes against the volumes of teachings that expound on the health benefits of stilling the mind, as in meditation. Our world is already over-stimulated to the point that many of us cannot keep up. Taking a stimulant on top of that will quite possibly drive us to exhaustion.
Food or Medicine?
That said, I am a believer that all plants have a purpose and we must try to understand them rather than pass judgment on them. Some plants are meant to be used as a food and are safe to eat regularly, others are more like medicines.
We also have to consider that the way we process coffee may seriously alter its properties. There is a long process from bean to brew, and many factors along the way that can change the effects of the original plant as nature intended it. Until more studies are done on the raw green bean, the research we have to work with is based on the coffee drink, and it’s clear from this research that coffee has medicinal properties. But is it safe for regular long-term use?
Sometimes the best way to understand a controversial substance is to look at how it was traditionally used. Before coffee became widely grown in so many parts of the world, it was considered an elite drink. In Europe as early as the mid-1600’s, coffee was only used in very small quantities after the large meal in the middle of the day. Being very acidic, coffee may stimulate the digestive process and act as a digestif. There is also research that suggests that coffee may help control after-meal blood sugar spikes. However, even using coffee in this way can have undesirable effects in the long-run:
For these reasons, I wouldn’t suggest an espresso with every meal, but in moderation and for the right body types, coffee may be supportive for digestion. However, that same cup of coffee on an empty stomach in the morning will stimulate the adrenals to make excess energy and stress hormones that may deplete the body’s reserves. As I mentioned, the boost one feels from coffee is in fact stimulating the body to prepare for an emergency.
- It is an intestinal irritant that can inflame the digestive tract.
- It is overly acidic, which can congest the lymph and detox pathways.
- It can desensitize the mucosa of the gut, causing chronic constipation.
- It is extremely dehydrating and can dry out the skin, gut, and respiratory tract.
It is possible that coffee has the capacity to create a higher state of health for a short period of time, so as to help the body best cope with the emergency state of an illness such as diabetes, Alzheimer’s, or Parkinson’s, to name a few that I mentioned earlier (see The Good section above).
My concern is the long-term effect of stimulating the body in this way. Given the facts, it seems more logical to recognize coffee as a drug or medicine: it boosts dopamine and drives degenerative hormones like cortisol, epinephrine (adrenaline), and norepinephrine, and inhibits calming GABA. These changes may be helpful in an emergency state or illness, but whether you would want your nervous system affected in this way in the long-term is questionable.
As for the reported health benefits, I attribute them to:
- Stimulating the body into a medicinal/emergency response to deal with a potential health threat.
- The wealth of antioxidants present in coffee, which certainly can’t be ignored. But has the roasting process altered the natural blueprint of coffee’s delicate balance of caffeine and antioxidants?
A Constitutional Approach
Ayurvedically speaking, certain constitutions will tolerate coffee better than others:
- Vata types: The hyper-metabolic vata types will be easily over-stimulated by coffee and quickly become depleted by the over-stimulation.
- Pitta Types: The already over-competitive pitta types will be driven even further by the coffee boost. Coffee is also very acidic and heating. This can be too much for the already hot pitta body type.
- Kapha types: The hypo-metabolic kapha types are easygoing and heavy by nature. Coffee may in some instances offer a medicinal boost to stimulate or enhance metabolic function of the body.
What’s your body type? Take our easy quiz and find out now.
Coffee as a drug or medicine may have its place. But how long will the benefits last? If you find yourself depending on coffee for boosting energy, mental clarity or keeping your bowels regular, this may be a problem as the benefits may be short-lived. Soon, more coffee may be needed to create these benefits, eventually leading to over-stimulation, adrenal exhaustion, negative side effects and even addiction. And, as with any addiction, it will ultimately leave us and our health at a disadvantage.
The green coffee extracts on the market may show some promise as preventative and healing agents, and I look forward to more studies about their efficacy. If we could harness the amazing benefits of this plant without risking the negative side effects, that would of course be ideal.
1. Diabetes Care. 2006 Feb;29(2):398-403
2. Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis. 2011 Jun;21(6):418-23
3. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2011 June 8;103(11):876-84
4. Aa Epidemiol. 2001;(7):458-65
5. J Alzheimers Dis. 2010;20 Suppl 1:S117-26
6. Mov Disord. 2007 Nov 15;22(15):2242-48
7. Amer J Clin Nutr. 2006 May;83(5)1039-46
8. J Human Hypertens. 2006 Dec;20(12):909-12
9. Hypertens Res. 2009 Niv;32(11):969-74
10. Am J Ren Phys. 2003. 284(1):F32-40
11. Pharmacology of Biochem and Behav. 2000 66(1):19-28
12. The Endocrinology of Agig, Science. 1997. 278(5337):419-24
13. Food Chem Toxicol. 2011 Oct 13. Epub2011 Oct 13. PMID: 22019894
14. JAMA. 1994. 272:1043-1048
15. Amer J Clin Nutr. 2001. 73(3):532-8
16. Amer J Hypertension. 203. 16(11):919-24
17. J Internal med. 1991. 230(4):299-305
18. Scand J Social med. 1996. 24(2):140-4
19. Amer J Clin Nutr. 2004. 80(4)862-7
20. Neuroendocrinology. 2003 38(2):227-31
21. Mol Pharm. 1988 May;33(5):481-85
22. Euro J Epidemiology. 2003 18(4):289-98
23. J Urology. 2004 172(2):555-8
24. Life Sciences. 1990 47(6):557-64
25. J Amer geriatric 1995 43(8):860-4
26. Inter J Impotence research. 2003 15(suppl 1:S8-14)
27. Gastroenterology 1995 108(1); 125-31
* Please Note: We cannot effectively or legally answer personal health questions here, for further assistance please consider a personalized Ayurvedic Consultation.